8” Round         serves   8-10      $19.95
10” Round       serves 10-12      $23.95
Small Sheet     serves 18-24      $32.95
Large Sheet    serves  38-44      $42.95
We carry over 60 cakes in stock and ready for pick-up!
Our REGULAR flavors include Classic Vanilla & Chocolate,
Bartman Deluxe, Cherries Jubilee, Chocolate Overdose, Mocha
Maddness, Oreo Deluxe, Mastic Mudd, and Strawberry Shortcake.
SPECIALITY cakes can be MADE-TO-ORDER
with any of our flavors with 1 DAY NOTICE.
We also have No-Fat and No-Sugar Cakes.
Have any cake decorated and custom made!
Choose any flavor, with your favorite picture
right on the cake!
Drop off your picture
for us to scan or email it in.  
We can place it on the cake
on edible "paper"
to make any occassion
very, very special.
Come in today, pick it up tomorrow!
Choose from hundreds
of graphics and designs,
or bring in your own for us
to scan and decorate your
special cake with.
Ice Cream Cottage Cakes are larger, fresher and so much more special than anything you can get at a supermarket.
ALL CUSTOM CAKES MUST BE ORDERED IN PERSON
Prices as of Oct. 18, 2009 and are subject to change
so be sure to use our coupons for special prices.....
Free Wi-Fi
Ice Cream Cottage
1590 Montauk Highway
Mastic, NY 11950
631-395-3580
icecreamcottage@optonline.net
Free Wi-Fi
Gift Certificates Are Available!    Major Credit Cards Accepted
We are open year round!  Every day 10AM-10PM  10:30pm on Friday & Saturday