BEST ICE CREAM
Located in historic Mastic, New York, the Ice Cream Cottage is the purveyor of the finest homemade ice cream on Long Island.
The Ice Cream Cottage opened its doors March of 1990 and is located on Montauk Highway in historic Mastic, New York on Long Island. Since then, the Ice Cream Cottage has won multiple awards.
The summer of 2016, the Ice Cream Cottage won by popular vote the coveted Best Ice-Cream Cone on Long Island award in Newsday. In 2012, the Ice Cream Cottage's world famous Chocolate Overdose was voted the Best Chocolate Ice Cream! The Ice Cream Cottage has been serving both quality classic ice cream and daring new ventures like our wine ice cream, Frose®.
The Ice Cream Cottage's interior harkens back to a simpler time yet, reflects the hip sensibilities of the up and coming area. The historic Mastic peninsula has long been Long Island's best kept secret—but not for long—with the Ice Cream Cottage bringing crowds to taste the Best Ice Cream on Long Island!
1590 Montauk Highway
Mastic, New York, 11950
GIFT CERTIFICATES AVAILABLE - ALL MAJOR CREDIT CARDS ACCEPTED.
ICE CREAM FLAVORS
If you don't see your favorite flavor here, Ask!
We can make it for you! Two-and-a-half gallon custom ice cream tubs made in any flavor with one day notice!
Ice Cream Cottage cakes are larger, fresher, and so much more special.
We carry over 60 cakes in stock and ready for pick-up!
Our regular in-stock cake flavors include classic Vanilla and Chocolate, Bartman Deluxe, Cherries Jubilee, Chocolate Overdose, Mocha Madness, Oreo Deluxe, Mastic Mudd, and Strawberry Shortcake.
SPECIALITY CAKES: Made-to-order with any of our flavors with ONE DAY NOTICE and must be ordered in-person.
We also have No-Fat and No-Sugar Cakes.
COOKIES AND GOODIES
All our Cookies and Goodies are great for any occasion! All holidays, family gatherings, office parties, school friends, religious organizations, doctors and health care workers, mail carrier, co-worker, sanitation worker, and teachers gifts. Terrific for any sports team party, business to business gifts or as a special treat for yourself!
The Ice Cream Cottage cookie selection includes favorites such as chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin, but also has a huge assortment of Italian and rainbow cookies.
Our cupcakes are made from scratch in small batches everyday and throughout the day. That way, we can make sure every cupcake comes out just right. We only use the finest and freshest ingredients. have our most popular ice-cream flavors topped with sugar decorations. Choose from a traditional bakery box or and Ice Cream Cottage gift box.
Peanut Butter Logs
Jazz It up Mix
M&M's Plain or Peanut
Sour Patch Kids
Assorted Fruit Slices
Assorted Sour Bites
Sugar- Free Candies
Milk, White or
Joyva Jell Rings
Malted Milk Balls
We can mix and match any combination of cookies, cupcakes, candies and nut trays together for the perfect customized gift for friends and family!
Print out these coupons or bring them in on your laptop, tablet or smartphone. Not to be combined with ANY OTHER OFFERS.
ICE CREAM CAKE COUPON
Receive a $2.00 discount on any cake in our freezer.
ICE CREAM SANDWICHES
Buy one six-pack of ice cream sandwiches, get 50% off a second six-pack.
SOFT ICE CREAM SUNDAE
Buy one soft ice-cream sundae get one free! This can be used any day of the week not just sundae special days!
Click the button below to sign up to our email list and receive a $5.00 COUPON ON YOUR BIRTHDAY FOR A CAKE.
At least a week prior to your birthday, sign up, and we will send an email for $5.00 off a freezer cake on your birthday. Show us your email and proof of your birthday and enjoy the best ice cream cake from our freezer!
THE ONLY TRULY ADULT DESSERT, FOR THOSE 21 AND OLDER
LESS THAN 5% ALCOHOL CONTENT