About Us
Making Super
Premium Ice Cream
The Ice Cream Cottage opened its doors March of 1990 and is located on Montauk Highway in historic Mastic, New York on Long Island. Since then, the Ice Cream Cottage has won multiple awards.
The summer of 2016, the Ice Cream Cottage won by popular vote the coveted Best Ice-Cream Cone on Long Island award in Newsday. In 2012, the Ice Cream Cottage's world famous Chocolate Overdose was voted the Best Chocolate Ice Cream!
The Ice Cream Cottage's interior harkens back to a simpler time yet, reflects the hip sensibilities of the up and coming area. The historic Mastic peninsula has long been Long Island's best kept secret—but not for long—with the Ice Cream Cottage bringing crowds to taste the Best Ice Cream on Long Island!
1
Stephan Linton
“The best ice cream in New York! Very small and personal space and not to mention their amazingly friendly staff”
2
Frank Ferrara
“The best... worth the wait from anywhere... heaven in a cone!”
Miguel Estella
3
“1st time ever going here and it was the best BEST ice cream I've ever had! Better then some famous known ice cream brands and the people that worked there were very helpful and friendly. Definitely will be going back!!!!”
Banana Nut Crunch
Bartman
Black Forest
Blackberry
Blueberry Italian Ice
Brownie Lovers Delight
Butter Pecan
Canoli Cream
Cappuccino Chip
Cherry Italian Ice
Cherry Vanilla
Cheesecake
Classic Chocolate
Chocolate Overdose
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
Coconut
Coffee
Cookies & Cream
Cookie Dough Chunk
Cookie Monster
Cotton Candy
Dulce De Leche
Fresh Banana
Lemon Italian Ice
Maple Walnut
Maraschino Cherry Chip
Mastic Mash
Mint Chocolate Chip
Mint Cookies & Cream
Mom’s Cake Batter
Moose Tracks
Orange Sherbet
Peanut Butter & Jelly
Peanut Butter Fudge
Pistachio Nut
Pralines & Cream
RAinbow cookie
Reese's Delight
Rocky Road
Rum Raisin
salted Caramel
S'mores
Snicker
Strawberry
Strawberry Cheesecake
Vanilla Bean
Vanilla Chip
Vanilla Fudge
Apple Pie
Apple Cider Donut
Blue Raspberry
Bubble Gum
Cantaloupe
Chocolate Coconut
Chocolate Covered Banana
Chocolate Covered Cherry
Chocolate Raspberry
Egg Nog
Hocus Pocus
Lemon
​Milky Way
Nutella
Orange Creamy
Peppermint
Pina Colada
Pineapple
Pumpkin
Raspberry
RED VELVET
Smith Point Splash
Tara’s Toffee
Watermelon
Glory Memolo - Customer
“Yummy ice cream in the world!
We drove 25 minutes
just to get this addicting ice cream.”
Tuesdays
Buy 1 get 1 FREE
SOFT SERVE SUNDAE
